Coming in strong at number four, the Strawberry Milkshake Pop-Tart is a fan-favorite, with shoppers reminiscing fondly about enjoying the flavor since childhood. "Strawberry Milkshake and Hot Fudge ...

Many referenced the weird maple flavor and odd aftertaste ... But if it's simply a new flavor Pop-Tart you want to try, check out our list for the best Pop-Tart flavors. (And if you're still ...

“Cookies and cream pop tart ice cream,” posited another. While we'd love a hot fudge sundae flavor, we’ll totally settle for these for now. A win is a win, right?