Not everyone can be the next American Idol — and judge Carrie Underwood had to make a difficult ... she wasn't the only star fans had their eye on this season — 22-year-old contestant Baylee ...

By Hannah Dailey As Carrie Underwood‘s career ... of the season 23 premiere, on which Underwood will make her debut as a judge — the country star rewatches her 2005 audition and gets emotional.